Skip to content
Interest of JusticeThe Leeuwarden Files

The defence · On the timeline

Filing
21 Feb 2024

C/17/190788 · Interlocutory proceedings on jurisdiction

Gates challenges the Dutch court's jurisdiction

Bill Gates (defence)

Defence filing · the court has not ruled on these claims

In 30 seconds

A preliminary motion in which Gates asks the court to declare it has no power to hear the claims against him, since he lives in the United States. He does not yet answer the claims themselves.

Cheat sheet

  1. Gates argues the basic rule is that a person must be sued in their home country, and he does not live in the Netherlands.
  2. He says the summons gives no basis for international jurisdiction and only relies on rules for which Dutch court hears a case.
  3. He denies his claims are closely enough linked to those against Hofstra, the Leeuwarden-based 'anchor' defendant.
  4. He reserves all other defences in case the court decides it does have jurisdiction.
  5. He asks for costs against the claimants.

Key passages · underlined

The general rule under Dutch law on jurisdiction is that a party must be sued before the court of its so-called ‘home country’, the forum rei (Article 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure).
Why it matters The starting point of Gates's challenge — he lives in Medina, Washington, not in the Netherlands.Page 2 · TheNetherlandsCase.com copy
Articles 99 and 107 of the Code of Civil Procedure merely govern the relative jurisdiction of your court. International jurisdiction cannot be derived from these provisions.
Why it matters Gates says the summons used the wrong legal rules. The court later decides jurisdiction under a different article.Page 3 · TheNetherlandsCase.com copy
Gates expressly reserves the right to raise other (formal and substantive) defences, if and in so far as your court were (nevertheless) to consider itself competent.
Why it matters Signals that Gates will fight the claims themselves if he loses on jurisdiction, as he later does.Page 2 · TheNetherlandsCase.com copy

Every defendant denies the claims, and the court has not ruled on them. Allegations are the claimants' pleaded positions, quoted as theirs. This is analysis and commentary, not legal advice. Interest of Justice is not a party to the case.

Keep this library open

Free to read, for good. Not free for IoJ to host.

Every document here was gathered, translated and checked by hand, and the whole record stays online for history, whatever happens to other sites. Interest of Justice is reader-funded, with no corporate or pharmaceutical money. If this library helped you, help keep it open.